| Games Played/Season | ||
| Number of Games | Name | Season |
| 34 | Darrell Borntrager | 2005 |
| 33 | Levi Ney | 2005 |
| 33 | Levi Ney | 2006 |
| 33 | Clint Gingerich | 2006 |
| 33 | Branson Ropp | 2008 |
| 33 | Levi Ney | 2008 |
| 33 | Collin Gingerich | 2008 |
| 33 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2008 |
| 32 | Tyler Coblentz | 2003 |
| 32 | Chase Gingerich | 2004 |
| 32 | Danny Hershberger | 2006 |
| 32 | Danny Hershberger | 2008 |
| Games Played/Career | ||
| Number of Games | Name | Career |
| 129 | Levi Ney | 2005-2008 |
| 118 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 108 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2005-2008 |
| 101 | Kenton Miller | 2000-2003 |
| 100 | Clint Gingerich | 2004-2007 |
| 99 | Jesse Ney | 2006-2009 |
| 97 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 96 | Troy Slaubaugh | 2001-2004 |
| 89 | Jon Derkson | 2004-2007 |
| 88 | Stephen Bender | 1994-1997 |
| 87 | Jerad Ropp | 2001-2004 |
| 85 | Tyson Schrock | 2003-2006 |
| 85 | Jason Litwiller | 2008-2011 |
| Season At-Bats | ||
| Number of At-Bats | Name | Season |
| 123 | Kenton Miller | 2003 |
| 118 | Rylan Miller | 2003 |
| 115 | Will Derksen | 2003 |
| 114 | Jerad Ropp | 2004 |
| 111 | Tyson Schrock | 2006 |
| 109 | Tyler Coblentz | 2004 |
| 108 | Darrell Borntrager | 2007 |
| 107 | Luke Yoder | 2004 |
| 107 | Darrell Borntrager | 2005 |
| 107 | Clint Gingerich | 2006 |
| Career At-Bats | ||
| Number of At-Bats | Name | Career |
| 386 | Levi Ney | 2005-2008 |
| 362 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 313 | Kenton Miller | 2000-2003 |
| 290 | Jesse Ney | 2006-2009 |
| 285 | Stephen Bender | 1994-1997 |
| 284 | Jerad Ropp | 2001-2004 |
| 278 | Clint Gingerich | 2004-2007 |
| 267 | Troy Slaubaugh | 2001-2004 |
| 262 | Will Derksen | 2000-2003 |
| 259 | Zach Grimm | 1996-1999 |
| Season Hits | ||
| Number of Hits | Name | Season |
| 54 | Levi Ney | 2008 |
| 53 | Tyson Schrock | 2006 |
| 51 | Darrell Borntrager | 2007 |
| 49 | Levi Ney | 2007 |
| 46 | Danny Hershberger | 2006 |
| 45 | Zach Grimm | 1999 |
| 45 | Danny Hershberger | 2007 |
| 41 | Lance Yoder | 1988 |
| 41 | Darrell Borntrager | 2005 |
| 40 | Zach Grimm | 1997 |
| 40 | Jesse Ney | 2009 |
| Career Hits | ||
| Number of Hits | Name | Career |
| 170 | Levi Ney | 2005-2008 |
| 168 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 123 | Zach Grimm | 1996-1999 |
| 117 | Jesse Ney | 2006-2009 |
| 97 | Stephen Bender | 1994-1997 |
| 97 | Darrell Borntrager | 2004-2007 |
| 96 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 91 | Clint Gingerich | 2004-2007 |
| 89 | Tyson Schrock | 2003-2006 |
| 85 | Lance Yoder | 1985-1988 |
| Season Batting Average | ||
| Batting Average | Name | Season |
| 0.643 | Zach Grimm | 1999 |
| 0.557 | Levi Ney | 2008 |
| 0.533 | Levi Ney | 2007 |
| 0.529 | Tony Miller | 1985 |
| 0.526 | Lance Yoder | 1987 |
| 0.500 | Lance Yoder | 1988 |
| 0.500 | Brooks Miller | 2008 |
| 0.488 | Aaron Swartzendruber | 1993 |
| 0.483 | Kevin Kemp | 1987 |
| 0.477 | Jeff Yoder | 1985 |
| 0.477 | Tyson Schrock | 2006 |
| Career Batting Average | ||
| Batting Average | Name | |
| 0.497 | Lance Yoder | 1985-1988 |
| 0.492 | Tony Miller | |
| 0.471 | Zach Grimm | 1996-1999 |
| 0.464 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 0.444 | Levi Ney | 2005-2008 |
| 0.403 | Jesse Ney | 2006-2009 |
| 0.400 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 0.399 | Darrell Borntrager | 2004-2007 |
| 0.395 | Marcus Hostetler | 1985-1987 |
| 0.369 | Branson Ropp | 2005-2008 |
| Season Runs-Batted-In | ||
| Runs-Batted-In | Name | Season |
| 74 | Levi Ney | 2008 |
| 57 | Levi Ney | 2007 |
| 47 | Danny Hershberger | 2008 |
| 46 | Darrell Borntrager | 2007 |
| 46 | Danny Hershberger | 2007 |
| 43 | Jesse Ney | 2009 |
| 39 | Lance Yoder | 1988 |
| 33 | Tyson Schrock | 2006 |
| 33 | Cameron Gingerich | 2011 |
| 32 | Collin Gingerich | 2009 |
| Career Runs-Batted-In | ||
| Runs-Batted-In | Name | |
| 179 | Levi Ney | 2005-2008 |
| 149 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 103 | Jesse Ney | 2006-2009 |
| 79 | Darrell Borntrager | 2004-2007 |
| 72 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 68 | Lance Yoder | 1985-1988 |
| 65 | Zach Grimm | 1996-1999 |
| 63 | Riley Hochstedler | 2008-2011 |
| 61 | Ryan Hostetler | 1987-1990 |
| 61 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2005-2008 |
| Season Runs | ||
| Number of Runs | Name | Season |
| 65 | Levi Ney | 2008 |
| 58 | Levi Ney | 2007 |
| 58 | Branson Ropp | 2008 |
| 50 | Ryan Bontrager | 2007 |
| 42 | Darrell Borntrager | 2007 |
| 40 | Tyson Schrock | 2006 |
| 39 | Rylan Miller | 2003 |
| 39 | Levi Ney | 2006 |
| 38 | Zach Grimm | 1999 |
| 38 | Cameron Gingerich | 2012 |
| 38 | Jesse Ney | 2008 |
| Career Runs | ||
| Number of Runs | Name | |
| 189 | Levi Ney | 2005-2008 |
| 125 | Ryan Bontrager | 2005-2008 |
| 108 | Branson Ropp | 2005-2008 |
| 102 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 95 | Jesse Ney | 2006-2009 |
| 94 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 82 | Zach Grimm | 1996-1999 |
| 73 | Stephen Bender | 1994-1997 |
| 72 | Collin Gingerich | 2006-2009 |
| 72 | Jason Litwiller | 2008-2011 |
| Season Home Runs | ||
| Number | Name | Season |
| 19 | Levi Ney | 2008 |
| 9 | Danny Hershberger | 2006 |
| 9 | Levi Ney | 2007 |
| 9 | Danny Hershberger | 2009 |
| 9 | Jesse Ney | 2009 |
| 8 | Tyson Schrock | 2006 |
| 8 | Danny Hershberger | 2008 |
| 8 | Riley Hochstedler | 2010 |
| 6 | Levi Ney | 2006 |
| 6 | Darrell Borntrager | 2007 |
| Career Home Runs | ||
| Number of Home Runs | Name | |
| 37 | Levi Ney | 2005-2008 |
| 30 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 15 | Jesse Ney | 2006-2009 |
| 15 | Riley Hochstedler | 2008-2011 |
| 11 | Ryan Hostetler | 1987-1990 |
| 11 | Tyson Schrock | 2003-2006 |
| 10 | Jon Troyer | 1997-1998 |
| 10 | Zach Grimm | 1996-1997 |
| 9 | Lance Yoder | 1985-1988 |
| 9 | Bradley Hershberger | 2004-2007 |
| Season Stolen Bases | ||
| Number of Stolen Bases | Name | Season |
| 33 | Zach Grimm | 1999 |
| 28 | Ledru Miller | 1997 |
| 22 | Jeremy Pickard | 1994 |
| 21 | Jackson Brokaw | 2009 |
| 20 | Corey Eberly | 1989 |
| 20 | Aaron Swartzendruber | 1993 |
| 20 | Rylan Miller | 2003 |
| 20 | Luke Yoder | 2004 |
| 20 | Branson Ropp | 2008 |
| 19 | Ryan Bontrager | 2008 |
| Career Stolen Bases | ||
| Number of Stolen Bases | Name | |
| 68 | Zach Grimm | 1996-1999 |
| 63 | Ryan Bontrager | 2005-2008 |
| 50 | Ledru Miller | 1995-1998 |
| 48 | Jeremy Pickard | 1992-1995 |
| 48 | Nate Miller | 1993-1996 |
| 42 | Aaron Swartzendruber | 1991-1994 |
| 37 | Jason Herhsberger | 1989-1992 |
| 37 | Luke Yoder | 2001-2004 |
| 36 | Branson Ropp | 2005-2008 |
| 35 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 32 | Mike Hershberger | 1987-1990 |
| Season Walks | ||
| Number of Walks | Name | Season |
| 37 | Riley Hochstedler | 2011 |
| 35 | Branson Ropp | 2008 |
| 31 | Levi Ney | 2008 |
| 30 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2008 |
| 29 | Clint Gingerich | 2007 |
| 28 | Kenton Miller | 2003 |
| 28 | Ethan Gingerich | 2008 |
| 26 | Mike Hershberger | 198? |
| 26 | Levi Ney | 2007 |
| 26 | Jackson Brokaw | 2011 |
| Career Walks | ||
| Number of Walks | Name | |
| 110 | Levi Ney | 2005-2008 |
| 75 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 70 | Riley Hochstedler | 2008-2011 |
| 65 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 61 | Branson Ropp | 2005-2008 |
| 58 | Kenton Miller | 2000-2003 |
| 56 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2005-2008 |
| 54 | Clint Gingerich | 2004-2007 |
| 54 | Jesse Ney | 2006-2009 |
| 53 | Greg Yoder | 1989-1992 |
| Season Slugging % (20 bats minimum) | ||
| Percentage | Name | Season |
| 1.278 | Levi Ney | 2008 |
| 1.022 | Levi Ney | 2007 |
| .971 | Zach Grimm | 1999 |
| 0.939 | Danny Hershberger | 2009 |
| 0.913 | Jesse Ney | 2009 |
| .898 | Ryan Hostetler | 1990 |
| .865 | Lance Yoder | 1988 |
| .853 | Tony Miller | 1985 |
| .825 | Lance Yoder | 1987 |
| .825 | Danny Hershberger | 2006 |
| .800 | Jon Troyer | 1998 |
| Career Slugging % (20 bats minimum) | ||
| Percentage | Name | |
| 0.858 | Levi Ney | 2005-2008 |
| 0.819 | Lance Yoder | 1985-1988 |
| 0.804 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 0.748 | Zach Grimm | 1996-1999 |
| 0.708 | Tony Miller | |
| 0.672 | Jesse Ney | 2006-2009 |
| 0.634 | Riley Hochstedler | 2008-2011 |
| 0.621 | Darrell Borntrager | 2004-2007 |
| 0.553 | Ryan Hostetler | 1987-1990 |
| 0.538 | Steve Dachtler | |
| Season Doubles | ||
| Number | Name | Season |
| 18 | Levi Ney | 2007 |
| 15 | Jesse Ney | 2009 |
| 14 | Lance Yoder | 1988 |
| 14 | Darrell Borntrager | 2005 |
| 14 | Danny Hershberger | 2007 |
| 13 | Levi Ney | 2005 |
| 13 | Darrell Borntrager | 2007 |
| 9 | Jerad Ropp | 2002 |
| 9 | Jesse Ney | 2008 |
| 9 | Christopher Perez | 2012 |
| Career Doubles | ||
| Number | Name | |
| 42 | Levi Ney | 2005-2008 |
| 33 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 31 | Jesse Ney | 2006-2009 |
| 29 | Darrell Borntrager | 2004-2007 |
| 24 | Lance Yoder | 1985-1988 |
| 22 | Jerad Ropp | 2001-2004 |
| 17 | Stephen Bender | 1994-1997 |
| 14 | Zach Grimm | 1996-1999 |
| 14 | Jeremy Pickard | 1992-1995 |
| 14 | Tyson Schrock | 2003-2006 |
| 14 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 14 | Christopher Perez | 2009-2012 |
| Season Triples | ||
| Number | Name | Season |
| 4 | Zach Grimm | 1998 |
| 3 | Kevin Kemp | 1987 |
| 3 | Levi Ney | 2008 |
| 2 | Tony Miller | 1985 |
| 2 | Jeff Yoder | 1985 |
| 2 | Lance Yoder | 1988 |
| 2 | Aaron Swartzendruber | 1993 |
| 2 | Nate Miller | 1995 |
| 2 | Zach Grimm | 1997 |
| 2 | Zach Grimm | 1999 |
| 2 | Jerad Ropp | 2003 |
| 2 | Jeremy Brokaw | 2005 |
| 2 | Bradley Bontrager | 2009 |
| 2 | Jackson Brokaw | 2011 |
| 2 | Cameron Gingerich | 2012 |
| Career Triples | ||
| Number | Name | |
| 8 | Zach Grimm | 1996-1999 |
| 4 | Kevin Kemp | |
| 4 | Aaron Swartzendruber | 1991-1994 |
| 4 | Levi Ney | 2005-2008 |
| 3 | Nate Miller | 1993-1996 |
| 3 | Ethan Gingerich | 2008-2011 |
| 3 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 3 | Christopher Perez | 2009-2012 |
| 2 | Jeff Yoder | |
| 2 | Tony Miller | |
| 2 | Chad Stoltzfus | 1985-1988 |
| 2 | Merlin Kauffman | 1987-1990 |
| 2 | Ryan Hostetler | 1987-1990 |
| 2 | Mike Hershberger | 1987-1990 |
| 2 | Jeremy Pickard | 1992-1995 |
| 2 | Jerad Ropp | 2001-2004 |
| 2 | Torey Miller | 2002-2005 |
| 2 | Bradley Bontrager | 2006-2009 |
| 2 | Jeremy Brokaw | 2003-2006 |
| PITCHING – Season Innings Pitched | ||
| Number of Innings | Name | Season |
| 69.70 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2007 |
| 68.33 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2008 |
| 63.00 | Tyler Coblentz | 2004 |
| 63.00 | Cameron Gingerich | 2011 |
| 59.60 | Lance Yoder | 1988 |
| 58.33 | Kenton Miller | 2003 |
| 58.33 | Victor Gingerich | 2005 |
| 58.00 | Will Derksen | 2003 |
| 58.00 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2005 |
| 57.67 | Cameron Gingerich | 2012 |
| Career Innings Pitched | ||
| Number of Innings | Name | |
| 256.33 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2005-2008 |
| 165.60 | Stephen Bender | 1994-1997 |
| 141.30 | Jeremy Yoder | 1989-1992 |
| 138.00 | Jason Hershberger | 1989-1992 |
| 128.33 | Jerad Ropp | 2001-2004 |
| 127.00 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 125.33 | Clint Gingerich | 2004-2007 |
| 119.33 | Kenton Miller | 2000-2003 |
| 117.33 | Tyler Coblentz | 2001-2004 |
| 115.60 | Mike Hershberger | 1987-1990 |
| Season Wins | ||
| Number of Wins | Name | Season |
| 11 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2007 |
| 11 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2008 |
| 8 | Lance Yoder | 1988 |
| 8 | Brooks Miller | 2008 |
| 8 | Danny Hershberger | 2008 |
| 8 | Collin Gingerich | 2009 |
| 7 | Lance Yoder | 1987 |
| 7 | Will Derksen | 2003 |
| 7 | Kenton Miller | 2003 |
| 7 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2005 |
| 7 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2006 |
| 7 | Clint Gingerich | 2007 |
| 7 | Cameron Gingerich | 2011 |
| Career Wins | ||
| Number of Wins | Name | |
| 36 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2005-2008 |
| 16 | Lance Yoder | 1985-1988 |
| 15 | Clint Gingerich | 2004-2007 |
| 14 | Jerad Ropp | 2001-2004 |
| 14 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 13 | Jeremy Yoder | 1989-1992 |
| 12 | Carson Miller | 2004-2007 |
| 12 | Collin Gingerich | 2006-2009 |
| 12 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 11 | Stephen Bender | 1994-1997 |
| 11 | Mike Hershberger | 1987-1990 |
| 11 | Chuck Miller | 1997-2000 |
| Season Earned Run Average (Based on per 7IP) | ||
| Average | Name | Season |
| 0.378 | Danny Hershberger | 2008 |
| 0.829 | Collin Gingerich | 2008 |
| 0.900 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2007 |
| 0.922 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2008 |
| 1.22 | Jon Derksen | 2006 |
| 1.24 | Jon Derksen | 2007 |
| 1.31 | Mike Hershberger | 1990 |
| 1.37 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2006 |
| 1.40 | Jesse Ney | 2007 |
| 1.45 | Kevin Kemp | 1986 |
| 1.45 | Victor Gingerich | 2004 |
| Career Earned Runs Average (50IP per season) | ||
| Average | Name | |
| 1.29 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 1.37 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2005-2008 |
| 1.45 | Jon Derksen | 2004-2007 |
| 1.72 | Collin Gingerich | 2006-2009 |
| 1.97 | Victor Gingerich | 2002-2005 |
| 2.17 | Jeremy Brokaw | 2002-2005 |
| 2.32 | Carson Miller | 2004-2007 |
| 2.68 | Clint Gingerich | 2004-2007 |
| 2.94 | Marcus Hostetler | 1985-1987 |
| 3.33 | Mike Hershberger | 1987-1990 |
| Season Strikeouts | ||
| Number of Strikeouts | Name | Season |
| 141 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2007 |
| 106 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2008 |
| 88 | Cameron Gingerich | 2012 |
| 74 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2006 |
| 74 | Jackson Brokaw | 2011 |
| 66 | Will Derksen | 2003 |
| 64 | Jackson Brokaw | 2010 |
| 64 | Brooks Miller | 2008 |
| 63 | Marcus Hostetler | 1987 |
| 57 | Cameron Gingerich | 2011 |
| 54 | Marcus Hostetler | 1985 |
| 54 | Jeremy Yoder | 1992 |
| 54 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2005 |
| 54 | Danny Hershberger | 2008 |
| Career Strikeouts | ||
| Number of Strikeouts | Name | |
| 381 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2005-2008 |
| 174 | Jackson Brokaw | 2008-2011 |
| 163 | Marcus Hostetler | 1985-1987 |
| 132 | Jeremy Yoder | 1989-1992 |
| 114 | Stephen Bender | 1994-1997 |
| 113 | Clint Gingerich | 2004-2007 |
| 111 | Jason Hershberger | 1989-1992 |
| 106 | Jerad Ropp | 2001-2004 |
| 104 | Danny Hershberger | 2006-2009 |
| 98 | Mike Hershberger | 1987-1990 |
| Season Saves | ||
| Number of Saves | Name | Season |
| 10 | Jon Derksen | 2005 |
| 5 | Jon Derksen | 2006 |
| 2 | Collin Gingerich | 2009 |
| 2 | Danny Hershberger | 2009 |
| 1 | Reggie Hochstedler | 2006 |
| 1 | Jon Derksen | 2007 |
| 1 | Collin Gingerich | 2008 |